25 Most Valuable Nickels

The CoinTrackers.com crew has compiled an awesome list we've dubbed 25 Most Valuable Nickels, and the page details the most valuable nickels minted in the United States from the late 1800's to the early 2000's. (Updated 2024) The values are descending so the most valuable are at the top. (so its a count up and not a countdown).

Bookmark this page know by hitting Ctrl+D or by selecting the favorites menu from your browser and then adding this page to your favorites. We hope you enjoy the resource.

• 1.) 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel - $4,228,955
• 2.) 1880 Shield Nickel - $20,000
• 3.) 1924 S Buffalo Nickel - $14,000
• 4.) 1926 S Buffalo Nickel - $7,600
• 5.) 1927 S Buffalo Nickel - $5,000
• 6.) 1881 Shield Nickel - $4,000
• 7.) 1883 Shield Nickel - $3,900
• 8.) 1867 Shield Nickel - $3,600
• 9.) 1920 D Buffalo Nickel - $3,500
• 10.) 1928 D Buffalo Nickel - $3,400
• 11.) 1918 D Buffalo Nickel - $3,300
• 12.) 1925 S Buffalo Nickel - $3,300
• 13.) 1924 D Buffalo Nickel - $3,000
• 14.) 1870 Shield Nickel - $3,000
• 15.) 1920 S Buffalo Nickel - $2,500
• 16.) 1872 Shield Nickel - $2,500
• 17.) 1919 D Buffalo Nickel - $2,350
• 18.) 1885 Liberty Head V Nickel - $2,328
• 19.) 1912 S Liberty Head V Nickel - $1,945
• 20.) 1886 Liberty Head V Nickel - $1,861
• 21.) 1877 Shield Nickel - $1,854
• 22.) 1873 Shield Nickel - $1,800
• 23.) 1874 Shield Nickel - $1,800
• 24.) 1916 D Buffalo Nickel - $1,780
• 25.) 1918 S Buffalo Nickel - $1,760

All US Nickels

• Thomas Jefferson Nickel
• Buffalo/Indian Head Nickel
• Liberty Head V-Nickel

Most Valuable Coins by Type...

• 25 Most Valuable Silver Dollars
• 25 Most Valuable Half Dollars
• 25 Most Valuable Quarters
• 25 Most Valuable Dimes
• 25 Most Valuable Nickels
• 25 Most Valuable Pennies
• 10 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollars
• 10 Most Valuable Peace Dollars
• 10 Most Valuable Barber Half Dollars
• 10 Most Valuable Walking Liberty Half Dollars