Notes: Look for a 3.5 or 3 and a half legged buffalo again make sure you are not buying a knock off or one that has had its leg scraped off. These errors are worth up to $19,000 so might want to have this sent of or only buy it if it has already been appraised and verified. Some people also call this an Indian Head Nickel
This section is more for experienced collectors only, and rates refer only to professionally graded and slabbed coins. If you are new to collecting the prices below may not make much sense.
Breakdown of pricing per condition for 1936 D Buffalo Nickel as follows.
- Grade EF40 = $15-$25
- Grade AU50 = $19-$31
- Grade AU53 = $23-$38
- Grade AU55 = $26-$44
- Grade AU58 = $30-$50
- Grade MS60 = $38-$56
- Grade MS61 = $38-$63
- Grade MS62 = $41-$69
- Grade MS63 = $45-$75
- Grade MS64 = $56-$94
- Grade MS65 = $90-$150
- Grade MS66 = $143-$238
- Grade MS67 = $600-$1,000
Is the list above a little overwhelming? If so, take 5 minutes to learn all about Coin Grading.
It's also important to note...Prices are subject to the same supply and demand laws as everything else. Coins sold at the same auction house 10x, would fetch drastically different bids each session. To raise your chances of receiving top dollar read How to Get the Most for your Coins.
We've personally researched these values. If you enjoy our content please return the favor and share this page with your friends.
How much is a 1936 D Buffalo Nickel worth?
In Average Circulated (AC) condition it's worth around $1.75, one in certified mint state (MS+) condition could bring as much as $67 at auction. This price does not reference any standard coin grading scale. So when we say Average Circulated, we mean in a similar condition to other coins circulated in 1936, and mint state meaning it is certified MS+ by one of the top coin grading companies. *** [?].
What are your coins really worth?
Use the handy-dandy calculator below to find the real value of any buffalo nickel in your collection.
The most valuable Buffalo Nickel's. Prices listed are for MS-65 certified. Visit the link to learn more about each coin.
|Sign In or Register to see all content.|
Want more? Click here to see the most valuable coins ever minted.
Hard to Find
What is the rarest Buffalo Nickel?
***Price subject to standard supply and demand laws, dealer premiums, and other market variations. Prices represent past values fetched at online auctions, estate sales, certified coins being sold by dealers, and user submitted values. While we wholeheartedly try to give honest price estimates there are many factors besides appearance, metal content, and rarity that help make up the coins overall value. Call or visit your local coin dealer for more information.
We use user submitted pictures please read that article if you are interested in adding your own.