2005 S Buffalo Nickel

Last updated: June, 19 2023

CoinTrackers.com estimates the value of a 2005 S Westward Journey Nickels Proof in average condition to be worth 5 cents, while one in mint state could be valued around $9.50.

2005 S Buffalo Nickel
Add to Favorites


The 2005 S Nickel with a Buffalo on the reverse has been titled American Bison nickel by the United States Mint.

The reverse has the words E Pluribus Unum.

Details above are for the proof version of the 2005 San Fran minted Buffalo Nickel.

2005 Buffalo Nickel Error Guide
2005 Buffalo Nickel Errors
(click to enlarge)

Improperly Annealed Error

The cause of this error is a bit of a mystery but it has been suggested then the planchets are struck either too long or when planchet temperatures are raised forcing some of the copper from the copper core to rise to the surface and overtake the nickel coating. Whatever the case may be, the 2005 Buffalo Nickel has many examples of this error floating around, and they are worth around $100 certified.

Clipped Planchet Error

When the planchets are repunched or restruck by the mechanism that cuts the circular planchets from the sheets of copper nickel, clipped planchet errors occur. Whenever a planchet is not fully ejected and on or under another planchet this can happen. Best described as a cookie cutter type error. A small crescent moon will be removed from the coin.

Die Gouge Error

Similar to a struck through error, Die Gouge Errors occur when an object is drug through the coin at some point creating strange objects and disturbances on the coin surfaces.

Copper Wash Error

Copper Wash Errors are similar to Improperly Annealed in that the subsurface copper rises to the coin surface. A copper wash is more dramatic in that the entire outer shell of the planchet appears to be coated in a thin layer (wash) of copper.

Speared Bison Error

Speared Bison / Speared Buffalo errors are known to exist on the 2005 Nickel. They are not all the same visually but they all share the same characteristic. A long line (called a spear) appears to enter and exit the buffalo's body.

How much is a 2005 S Buffalo Nickel worth?

In Average Circulated (AC) condition it's worth around 5 cents, one in certified mint state (MS+) condition could bring as much as $10 at auction. This price does not reference any standard coin grading scale. So when we say Average Circulated, we mean in a similar condition to other coins circulated in 2005, and mint state meaning it is certified MS+ by one of the top coin grading companies. *** [?].

What are your coins really worth?

Use the handy-dandy calculator below to find the real value of any Westward Journey Nickels in your collection.

whats your nickel worth

Most Valuable

The most valuable Westward Journey Nickels's. Prices listed are for MS-65 certified. Visit the link to learn more about each coin.

Image Year Mint Worth
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 S $15
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 S $15
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 S $12.50
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 P $10
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 D $10
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 S $9.50
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 P $8
Westward Journey Nickels 2004 D $8
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 D $5.50
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 P $5
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 D $5
Westward Journey Nickels 2005 $5
Sign In or Register to see all content.
1989 P $345.22
1989 $345,000
1989 D $345
Image Name Mint Worth

Want more? Click here to see the most valuable coins ever minted.

***Price subject to standard supply and demand laws, dealer premiums, and other market variations. Prices represent past values fetched at online auctions, estate sales, certified coins being sold by dealers, and user submitted values. While we wholeheartedly try to give honest price estimates there are many factors besides appearance, metal content, and rarity that help make up the coins overall value. Call or visit your local coin dealer for more information.